Old Mill Preserve Homes under $500,000

Old Mill Preserve Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Old Mill Preserve, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Palmetto, Florida. This charming subdivision offers a perfect blend of serene living and modern convenience, making it an ideal choice for families, retirees, and anyone looking to enjoy the beautiful Florida lifestyle.

Old Mill Preserve is known for its picturesque surroundings, featuring lush green spaces and scenic walking trails that invite you to explore the natural beauty of the area. With its close-knit community vibe, residents often enjoy friendly gatherings and neighborhood events, fostering a sense of belonging and camaraderie.

One of the standout features of Old Mill Preserve is its affordability, with a variety of homes available for under $500,000. This makes it an attractive option for first-time homebuyers and those seeking to downsize without sacrificing quality or comfort. The homes in this subdivision are thoughtfully designed, offering modern amenities and spacious floor plans that cater to diverse lifestyles. Many properties boast beautiful outdoor spaces, perfect for entertaining or simply soaking up the Florida sunshine.

Conveniently located near major highways, Old Mill Preserve provides easy access to nearby cities and attractions, including the stunning Gulf Coast beaches, vibrant shopping districts, and delicious dining options. For families, the community is served by well-regarded schools, ensuring a quality education for children of all ages.

Discover the charm of Old Mill Preserve, where affordable living meets a warm, welcoming community. Your dream home awaits in this delightful Palmetto neighborhood!

Newest Old Mill Preserve Homes under $500,000

5823 Oak Mill Terrace, Palmetto
$365,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Old Mill Preserve SubDv. ⋅ 34221 Zip Code
From Sunrise Coffee to Spectacular Sunsets — Enjoy the Best of Florida Living! Welcome to 5823 Oak Mill Terrace, a charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offering approximately 1,390 square feet of comfortable living space in the desirable Old Mill Preserve community of Palmetto. Built in 2017, this thoughtfully designed home features an inviting open great-room floor plan, a two-car garage, and two exceptional screened outdoor living spaces that truly set it apart. Start your mornings with a fresh cup of coffee on the huge screened-in front lanai, the perfect spot to welcome the sunrise, enjoy the gentle Florida breezes, and ease into your day. As evening approaches, retreat to the peaceful rear lanai, where tranquil pond views extend toward a beautiful conservation area, creating a picturesque natural setting for watching wildlife and enjoying spectacular Florida sunsets. Inside, the open-concept living and dining areas provide a comfortable, welcoming atmosphere for everyday living and entertaining. The practical split-bedroom layout offers privacy for family and guests, while the home's easy-flowing design makes the most of its living space. Whether you're relaxing with your morning coffee, entertaining friends, or unwinding as the sun sets over the pond, this home offers a wonderful connection to nature and the relaxed Florida lifestyle. Two screened lanais, peaceful water and conservation views, and beautiful sunrises and sunsets — all from the comfort of home. Discover your own slice of Florida paradise at 5823 Oak Mill Terrace!

5823 Oak Mill Terrace, Palmetto

5918 Oak Mill Terrace, Palmetto
$410,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Old Mill Preserve SubDv. ⋅ 34221 Zip Code
Beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home with a bonus office/den, tucked into the gated community of Old Mill Preserve. Pride of ownership shows throughout, from the perfectly manicured lawn to the move-in ready interior. With mature preserve trees along one side of the home, you'll have no neighbors on that side, plus a peaceful pond and preserve view from the back patio, family room, and primary bedroom. Inside, natural light fills the home throughout. The dining area and family room each open to the screened porch through sliding glass doors, creating an easy flow for relaxing or entertaining while taking in the water and preserve views. Upstairs, the primary suite offers the same gorgeous pond and preserve views, a spacious walk-in closet, and an ensuite bath with dual sinks, a garden tub, and an enclosed glass shower. A connected office/den off the primary suite makes a great home office or private sitting area. On the opposite side of the second floor, you'll find three additional bedrooms and a full bathroom with dual sinks, nicely separated from the primary suite for added privacy. The laundry room on the main floor also includes bonus storage tucked under the stairs. Recent updates include a new roof (2024), hurricane impact windows on the second floor (2025), and AC (2017), giving buyers extra peace of mind. Old Mill Preserve is a gated community with low HOA fees and no CDD, located just minutes from Virgil Mills Elementary, Buffalo Creek Middle School, Buffalo Creek Park, and Buffalo Creek Golf Course. You'll also have quick access to Publix, Aldi, Lowe's, HomeGoods, Crunch Fitness, and Ellenton Premium Outlets, plus easy access to US-301, I-75, and I-275 for a simple commute to Tampa, St. Petersburg, Sarasota, Lakewood Ranch, and beyond. With continued growth and new restaurants, shopping, and development coming to the Palmetto and Parrish area, this is a wonderful opportunity in a convenient, growing location. Schedule your showing today!

5918 Oak Mill Terrace, Palmetto

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!